Moving Anti-Austerity Protests Past Grievances And Toward Political Objectives

It’s so difficult to say anything that hasn’t already been said about the crisis in Europe. This past Saturday, I watched closely as Portuguese rallied in enormous numbers against the foreign imposed austerity measures. The energy of tens of thousands filling the streets is momentarily intoxicating as ever, especially when they sing Grandola, Vila Morena, a song charged with revolutionary energy and optimism. But as soon as the last verse is sung, the crowds begin to demobilize; videos, photos and memories are the only evidence that there was even a protest of such scale. Because the next day, as the political leaders remain indifferent, the discussion already switches to the next austerity measures and the next bleak economic headline.

This has played out countless times in each crisis hit country in the Euro Zone. The social anxiety of the public spills out onto the streets as anger and then recedes back into anxiety. Then, a sense of defeat sinks in during the following weeks and months, until the latest provocation of yet more sacrifices transforms that anxiety into yet more protests by thousands of angry, crisis fatigued citizens.

I think the reason for this is obvious, though I suspect many who attend, promote and organize these protests don’t want to hear it. The protests aren’t to challenge the government, but only to probe the government’s resolve. When the government’s resolve proves to be unshaken, since there is no policy alternative within the current framework of the Troika, there’s no where to go but to return to that state of social anxiety. The point A to point B marches play it safe, expressing their demands but not setting out an objective that is to be reached through various tactics. I would call it public relations but I think organizers of protests like Que Se Lixe A Troika sincerely believe mass marches every few months can stop the austerity. I’m here to say that this is a miscalculation.

It’s easy to see how opposition to austerity will eventually triumph, the policies undoubtedly cause tremendous economic and social damage. Each round of cuts and tax hikes align more people against the government and the international creditors known as the Troika. Inevitably, the protests in Spain, Greece, and Portugal has swelled with each passing year. But this slow grind of declining legitimacy for governments in southern Europe has great risk. As we can see in Greece, a neo-nazi party, Golden Dawn, has surged onto the highest stage of Greek politics, now polling 3rd overall, this as its militias violently attack immigrants on the streets. Spanish society, if eroded by a similar amount of austerity, could see regional and cultural differences hardened. Portugal, with no parliamentary far-right in existence, could be tempted by similar extreme nationalists in the years ahead as frustration with mainstream parties grow.

There is a clock ticking away in Europe, but it isn’t necessarily counting down till the day when the streets banish the troika’s authority. Rather, this is a clock ticking down to when that far-right menace erupts to break up the European project on its own terms, all the while fanning once dormant national rivalries. This isn’t without precedent in Europe. It was during the ’80s that another federation of nations, Yugoslavia, was subject to fierce austerity which provokes strike action like we see in Europe today. But they fell short, and by the early ’90s, nationalists would assert themselves and give Europe another bloody chapter of warfare and ethnic cleansing.

The forces opposed to austerity must set political objectives, and deploy tactics to reach those objectives. This doesn’t have to mean preparing for insurrection and siege of congress like some in Spain are organizing for. In Portugal, where political violence isn’t what it is in Greece or Spain, daily mobilizations could replicate the success of the protests of late in Bulgaria. With the right-wing coalition government in Portugal plotting further austerity to the tune of 4 billion euros in cuts, the urgency should be widely shared. The streets must themselves become political actors, not merely a visual of the discontent politicians see in any monthly political survey. There has to be a willingness by anti-austerity forces to fail, to overplay their hand. It doesn’t require the approval of the whole country or hundreds of thousands of people to get involved. Even thousands, if they are committed and share common purpose and tactics, can achieve a government’s resignation. Those thousands shouldn’t be hard to find amid the misery that exists across southern Europe today.


5 responses to “Moving Anti-Austerity Protests Past Grievances And Toward Political Objectives”

  1. ejh says :

    Even thousands, if they are committed and share common purpose and tactics, can achieve a government’s resignation.

    How, do you think? What kind of thing are you thiniking of?

    • fouryawkeyway says :

      I really don’t want to sound like I’m giving marching orders. I cited Bulgaria, where protesters simply stayed on the streets for days instead of dispersing after planned point a to point b march. I also mentioned a more radical approach being considered in Spain, Asedia El Congreso, (besiege congress), still need to embed the links. bare with me, it’s 3am here 🙂

  2. ejh says :

    I would be very sceptical indeed of the “besiege Congress” plan (which I saw in your previous post. Even if you could get the numbers required to do such a thing, which I doubt, I don’t believe such a move would have support among the wider movement, let alone the Spanish people.

    Demonstrations that just keep on going, Bulgaria-style: a better idea, I think, but I’m not sure movements like that are called, so much as happen!

    I do think people have been emboldened, or at very least cheered up, by recent events (Bulgaria, Portugal, Italy). Not that I’m really in touch with what goes on.

    • fouryawkeyway says :

      For what it’s worth, several thousands have already signed onto the besiege congress event in Spain, and it’s still well over a month and a half away. I think we’ll be surprised by how many show up. After very violent police repression over the general strike & september 25th protest, the Spanish state has made a lot of enemies out of a lot of frustrated, unemployed youths.

  3. RigoHC says :

    I think throughout the crisis the left has not been as conscious as it should be that a possible outcome of Austerity will be not revolutionary but a rise of the far right as happened in the 1930’s the left should prepare more this possibility to not be blindsided by it

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: